Meltzer’s Classics: Katsuyori Shibata vs Tomohiro Ishii (4/8/13)

Image result for ishii shibata g1
It’s safe to say that Shibata was coming in fast. Credit: NJPW

Damn, I was almost giddy with excitement about getting to check this one out. Ishii and Shibata are two of my favourite wrestlers of all time, yet, somehow, I’ve never seen this match. Time to change that.

The tone for this war was set before the bell even rang. Ishii and Shibata stood in their separate corners crouched forward like sprinters, bouncing on their toes and ready to charge across the ring. Before the ding that sent them off had even faded out, they were meeting in the middle, throwing themselves at each other in a desperate struggle to prove who the tougher man was.

What followed was a fight. Plain and simple. These two beat each other black and blue, the dull thud of kicks, chops and elbows echoing around the Osaka building with the only thing matching it in volume being the yells of the crowd as they roared these two warriors on. You could call this wrestling, but it looked a lot more like a brawl.

And Shibata and Ishii loved it. There were moments in the match where they were stepping back and inviting each other to have a swing – at one point even going as far as taking it in turns to drop to a knee. Ishii to accept a kick and Shibata a chop. They revelled in pushing each other to the limit, seeing how much they could take before falling back. By the end, both men were staggering around the ring, still throwing elbows even as they could barely stand.

An observation that points to this match’s secret weapon, it might have been a war with two hard as nails bastards beating each other senseless, but the selling was incredible. Both men made it very clear that those strikes hurt, which made it all the more incredible when they kept coming forward. The kick outs at one seem unbelievable because we’ve seen them both reel back, eyes rolling into their foreheads and legs turning to jelly after a simple kick or elbow, so the Lariats and Suplexes look like death blows.

The truly mindblowing thing? It only lasts twelve minutes. All of that is crammed into a time which would merely be the first act of many a New Japan main event. Ishii and Shibata ram their feet down on the accelerators and get more into those twelve minutes than some get into a career. It’s astonishing.

I’ve made it kind of obvious that I loved this match. However, I will say that there was one moment that made me flinch, as they took it in turns to headbutt each other. Obviously, at the time, there were no lasting repercussions, but with what happened to Shibata later, I can’t watch him do that without grimacing. It doesn’t take away from what this match is, though, a battle between two of the best.

Watch New Japan:

If you enjoyed this review, please consider contributing to my Ko-fi, even the smallest amount is appreciated.

3 thoughts on “Meltzer’s Classics: Katsuyori Shibata vs Tomohiro Ishii (4/8/13)

Add yours

  1. Love the write-up, I really enjoy this series and glad that you’ve brought it back recently. In your last Meltzer’s Classics write-up, you mentioned having difficulty finding certain matches, I can send you a spreadsheet someone made with all the matches with links to the ones that have footage if you’d like.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: